top of page
Search

Old vs. New Shingles: Why Preserving Your Existing Roof May Be Smarter Than Replacing It

  • john01077
  • Jun 13
  • 3 min read

If your roof was installed during or before the early 2000s, you might be surprised to learn they were built with heavier, more durable shingles than most roofing materials on the market today. That’s right — many existing roofs still have better construction quality than what you’d get with a full tear-off and replacement.


And that’s exactly why shingle rejuvenation is gaining traction as a cost-saving, property-preserving, and insurance-protective solution for thousands of Michigan homeowners.



The Truth About Today’s Shingles

Modern shingles may look nice on paper, but here’s what many owners and managers don’t realize: they’re often thinner and lighter than the shingles used 15–25 years ago.

  • Older shingles were built with asphalt-rich felt mats and could weigh up to 300+ pounds per roofing square (100 sq ft).

  • Today’s shingles use fiberglass mats with significantly less asphalt, sometimes weighing as little as 180 pounds per square.


Why the change? Manufacturers moved to lighter, cheaper materials to cut costs and improve fire ratings — but in the process, many shingles lost long-term durability and resilience, especially under harsh weather conditions.


That Makes Older Roofs Ideal for Rejuvenation

Here’s the good news: all that extra asphalt in older shingles makes them perfect candidates for rejuvenation. These shingles have the raw material to hold protective asphalt oil — they’ve just lost that oil over time and its protective and aesthetic properties.


Instead of paying to tear off and replace a heavy-duty roof with something less substantial:

✅ We restore flexibility and waterproofing by replenishing lost oils.

✅ We extend shingle life by 5–15 years, starting at 10% of the cost of replacement.

✅ We avoid 2–3 tons of landfill waste per unit — a win for the budget and the planet.

✅ We include free inspection, cleaning, and minor repairs to protect your property.


When Is Rejuvenation Better Than Replacement?

Rejuvenation isn’t the right fit for every roof — and we won’t recommend it unless the roof is structurally sound without sublayer damage. But if the shingles are intact and still have most of their granules? Rejuvenation may be the smarter, more cost-effective choice:

Category

Rejuvenated Older Roof

New Roof with Thin Shingles

Asphalt Content

High – restored with treatment

Low – cannot be added later

Durability

Often superior to entry-level replacements

Varies widely by product tier

Cost

75–85% less than full replacement

Full replacement cost (4–6× higher)

Impact Resistance

Heavier = more robust

Often lighter, less hail-resistant

Environmental Impact

Keeps shingles out of landfills

Adds to construction waste stream


What Property Owners and Managers Should Consider

Shingle rejuvenation is more than a temporary patch — it’s a way to significantly delay major property expenditures and preserve existing property value in a cost-effective, environmentally responsible way.


When paired with annual roof tune-ups, rejuvenation can:

  • Reduce emergency roof repairs and expenses up to 90%

  • Help defer major capital expenditures

  • Immediately improve roof integrity and appearance

  • Maintain insurance coverage through improved roof condition


And in many cases, your existing shingles outperform what’s available today — especially on properties built before 2002.


Get the Facts — Not the Sales Pitch

At MI Roof Renewal, we’ve treated over 1,000 Michigan homes with our eco-friendly rejuvenation solution. If your shingles are intact but aging, we can restore performance and extend life — without the disruption and cost of roof replacement.


Schedule a Free Roof Evaluation Today

Let us inspect your roof, measure their condition, and provide professional documentation and recommendation — not just a quote. If your roof qualifies, we’ll show you how rejuvenation can save up to 75% versus replacement over a guaranteed 15-year extended roof lifespan.


Call 248-487-9300 or request a free inspection and estimate at MiRoofRenewal.com.

 
 
 

Comments


MI Roof Renewal Logo - A New Day for Your Roof
Order Your On-Line Estimate Today
Call Us for Immediate Response
Email Us for Prompt Response
Check out our Facebook Page
Google 5-Star Reviews
RRC member badge_edited.jpg
HA badges_edited.jpg

© MI Roof Renewal LLC 2020-2024, RoofRestor trademark of BioBased Spray Systems 

bottom of page